Breaking

Supreme Court Returns Shipper Liability Case to California Court in Post-Montgomery Landscape

FW Desk News

FreightWatch.News

·

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The U.S. Supreme Court issued a Grant, Vacate, Remand order Monday in Casarez vs. Irigoyen Farms, sending the case back to a California appellate court to reconsider shipper and receiver liability questions. The decision reopens debate over whether shippers and their customers can face legal exposure following accidents. The case stems from a September 2019 crash near Fresno that killed Olivia Mendoza. An independent contractor driving produce from Irigoyen Farms to a Walmart distribution center in Nevada ran a stop sign and struck Mendoza's vehicle. The driver received a two-year sentence for vehicular manslaughter. Earlier rulings had cleared both Irigoyen and Walmart of liability. The produce was contracted through Royal Violet Logistics, then SIO Logistics, before Gold Coast Logistics carried the load. The GVR order keeps open the possibility that the Supreme Court will take up the shipper liability issue in the future.

More Breaking coverage

Railcar Supply Crunch Accelerates as Fleet Deficit Hits 17-Month StretchAmazon Opens First Puerto Rico Delivery Station to Speed Up ShipmentsSpot Rates Surge Despite Falling Diesel Costs, Signaling Tight CapacityLogistics Firms Struggling to Convert AI Investments Into Tangible ReturnsTruckload Rates Plateau at $2.58/Mile as Carrier Momentum SlowsLA Port Sets 118-Year Record With 5M Containers in Five MonthsAll Breaking news →
← Back to Freightwatch.news